Shall or Will?

search our site by Craig Shrives

What Is the Difference between "Shall" and "Will"?

"Shall" and "will" are often interchangeable, but there are some nuances to consider when choosing which to use.

Nowadays, Americans tend not to use "shall" to form the future tense. In British English, "shall" is still used to form the future tense, particularly when the subject is "I" or "we." However, most Brits now use "will." This is a relatively new development.

This graph shows the recent decline of "shall" in British English.
(Create this graph yourself using Google's Ngram Viewer.)

More about "Shall" and "Will"

Here are two distinctions between "shall" and "will" that have been traditionally followed. It would be inaccurate to describe these as rules nowadays, but you can use these to sway your decision.

• (1) Use "shall" when the subject is "I" or "we."
• I shall use my discretion. (traditionally)
• (2) Use "will" when the subject is not "I" or "we."
• He will use his discretion. (traditionally)

In the UK, these two distinctions still exist if the sentence is a question. (For clarity, these are still rules.) For example:

• Shall we discuss this matter tomorrow?
(Of interest, the Irish would use "will" here, not "shall.")
• Will they discuss this matter tomorrow?

Of interest, if you need to convey that something must happen (typically out of a sense of duty), then you can swap "shall" for "will" (and vice versa). For example:

• I will use my discretion.
(Traditionally, using "will" instead of "shall" provided emphasis.)
• He shall use his discretion.
(Traditionally, using "shall" instead of "will" provided emphasis.)

You can still use this technique, but, in truth, the nuance sought is likely to go unnoticed by most of your readers. (There is more on this below.)

Even More about "Shall" and "Will"

The main use of the auxiliary verbs "will" and "shall" is to form the future tense. For example:

• I will arrive on Tuesday.
• I shall arrive on Tuesday.

However, these days, the use of "shall" to form the future tense is becoming rarer (especially in the US), and it is safe to use "will" every time. In fact, to say it's "safe to use "will" every time" is understating the case. Unless you're asking a question, it is largely expected (particularly in the US).

The Traditional Rules for Forming the Future Tense with "Will" and "Shall"

The traditional rules for forming the future tense with "will" and "shall" are as follows:

Person	Pronoun Noun	Future Tense	Example
1st Person Singular	I	shall	I shall be there soon.
2nd Person Singular	You	will	You will be there soon.
3rd Person Singular	He, She, It	will	He will be there soon.
1st Person Plural	We	shall	We shall be there soon.
2nd Person Plural	You	will	You will be there soon.
3rd Person Plural	They	will	They will be there soon.

Just to reiterate though, nowadays, it is okay to use "will" in every instance.

Conveying a Sense of Importance or Duty with "Will" and "Shall"

If something is to happen in the future and you want to convey the idea that it must definitely happen (especially out of a sense of duty), then it all switches. In other words, it goes like this:

Person	Pronoun Noun	Future Tense	Example
1st Person Singular	I	will	I will attend the meeting.
2nd Person Singular	You	shall	You shall attend the meeting.
3rd Person Singular	He, She, It	shall	He shall attend the meeting.
1st Person Plural	We	will	We will attend the meeting.
2nd Person Plural	You	shall	You shall attend the meeting.
3rd Person Plural	They	shall	They shall attend the meeting.

Look at these examples:

• I will guarantee your safe passage.
(If this were just the future tense (i.e., without any sense of duty attached), then, traditionally, it should read "I shall guarantee ." As it doesn't, the use of "will" could convey a sense of duty to some of your readers. However, the overwhelming majority of your readers are likely to think that you've just opted for "will" over "shall" as a way of forming the future tense. In other words, they won't give it a second thought.)
• You shall ask a question on recruitment at the end of the presentation.
(If this were just the future tense (i.e., without any sense of duty attached), then it should read "You will ask...." Again, for some of your readers, the use of "shall" could convey a sense of duty, but it won't for most.)

Nowadays, this is just a point of academic interest. Few of your readers are likely to spot that you've switched from "will" to "shall" (or vice versa) to convey a sense of importance or duty.

"Shall" Is Still Used in Questions

From what you've read so far, you might be getting the idea that "shall" is on its last legs as a word. You might be thinking it's hot on the heels of "whom" to reach the word graveyard where words like "hither" and "whence" have lain to rest. However, that's not accurate. "Shall" is alive and well when it comes to questions posed in the first person (i.e., with "I" and "we"). For example:

• Shall I talk in a Scottish accent during the meeting?
• What shall we talk about?
• Was that the dog? Shall I open the window?

"Will" and "Shall" in Contractions

When talking or writing informally, you might not have to worry about whether to use "shall" or "will" because the contractions are likely to be the same.

Full Versions	Contraction
I shall I will	I'll
You shall You will	You'll
He/She/It shall He/She/It will	He'll / She'll / It'll
We shall We will	We'll
You shall You will	You'll
They shall They will	They'll

This overlap does not occur with "will not" and "shall not" (the negative versions). The contraction for "shall not" is "shan't." The contraction for "will not" is "won't."

Ready for the Test?